Talk:going to

From Wiktionary, the free dictionary
Latest comment: 3 years ago by Backinstadiums in topic "I'm gonna to New York"
Jump to navigation Jump to search

request[edit]

The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language, page 172, reads

Are you going to be helping them again this year? (where the non-progressive might be construed as a request: in Will you go to the shops this afternoon? the salient interpretation is as a request to you to go to the shops. 

--Backinstadiums (talk) 17:13, 17 October 2019 (UTC)Reply

Matters of taxonomy[edit]

In my own lexicon of compositional terms, going to + infinitive:

  • is strictly comprised of a verb phrase wherein "going to" is neither a phrasal modal nor a phrasal auxiliary verb, despite the conceptually overlapping grammatical considerations
  • is strictly comprised of a "continuative participle" (i.e. not a "present participle") that entails a subsequent inchoate action relating to a future aspect, i.e. NOT a true future tense comprised of a present participle, despite the conceptually overlapping temporal considerations

Moments ago I posted an edit that comports with the relevant corpus of taxonomy in Wiktionary (which rely on traditional linguistic perspectives rather than on modern developments). However, the edit doesn't fully square with the terms in my own lexicon. I apologize to anyone who is familiar with the modern terminology in my own book, recognizes me as the author of the freshly-minted going to edit, and thus recognizes the divergent terminology involved.

Notice to the non-linguistically challenged: If you rue the thrust of the changes entailed in my edit given your understanding of how modern linguistic elements have obsoleted some of the terms in the going to article, please resist any urge to revert my edit. Instead, please submit a wholesale revision of the article.

Notice to the linguistically unevolved: If you're unable to disambiguate (or you otherwise disagree with) the thrust of the changes entailed in my edit, please resist any knee-jerk impulse to revert the edit. Instead, please acquaint yourself with the relevant developments in linguistic terminology and then judiciously offer your own corresponding edits.

Cheers. --Kent Dominic (talk) 05:02, 22 April 2020 (UTC)Reply

"I'm gonna to New York"[edit]

Surely what's meant is "I'm gonna New York" --Backinstadiums (talk) 16:08, 9 August 2020 (UTC)Reply